(618) 408-1446

Do You Need a New Toilet? Here Are 5 Signs to Look Out For

A homeowner consults with a hardware store employee to select a new toilet for his home in Collinsville, IL.

If you’re having problems with your current toilet, you need to report your concerns to a professional. You could end up spending a fortune on repairs if you don’t get answers. Worse yet, if you ignore the issue, you could end up with a plumbing disaster. Because knowledge is power, we’ve put together a guide to help you determine when to replace your troublesome toilet. If you decide to replace your toilet with a newer model, you’ll want the best plumbers with the best tools and materials to install it for you. When you want a professionally thorough job and a satisfaction guarantee, contact our experts at Morrison Plumbing in Collinsville, IL.

Age of Your Toilet

Toilet leaks can go unnoticed for months. You are not a careless toilet owner—you simply may not realize you have a leak. You won’t see water on the floor like you would if your tank was cracked.

How do you know if you have a leak since leaks can be difficult to detect? We advise examining your water bill. Toilets that leak waste an excessive amount of water. If your bill suddenly rises without explanation, check for a leak.

The unfortunate result of a leaky toilet is damaged flooring and subflooring. If left untreated, a leaking toilet in an upstairs bathroom can also cause water damage in the rooms downstairs. If your toilet is older and leaking, replacing it is the most cost-effective option.


A cracked toilet tank in a bathroom decorated with floral wallpaper in Collinsville, IL.

A Crack in Your Tank

Have you noticed any puddles near the toilet’s base? Feel free to question your children or spouse about their aiming, but if the liquid is clear, you may have a cracked tank.

You can begin by conducting your own inspection. Examine the tank from the inside and outside. The location of the crack determines whether or not a repair is necessary. If it’s below the water line, you may need to replace the toilet tank. Most homeowners will then replace the entire toilet.

Tank cracks are not always visible, especially if they are hairline fractures. If you can’t find a visible crack, call a plumber for a more thorough plumbing inspection.

A Constant Flushing or Running Toilet

The constantly running toilet is one of the most annoying plumbing issues you can experience. Of course, water flowing for a short period of time after flushing is perfectly normal. When water continues to flow from the tank to the bowl, this is a bad sign.

A running toilet wastes water in addition to making an obnoxious noise. While a running toilet may not necessitate an immediate replacement, it should not be ignored. Running toilets are usually caused by a faulty flapper valve. Wiggling the valve can sometimes temporarily fix the seal. When the toilet starts working again, you’ll most likely need to replace the flapper.

While we do not recommend replacing a toilet if this is the only issue, this fix does not always work. The tank of the toilet may have a broken fill valve or another problem. This is why it is best to have an experienced plumber take a closer look at your system. A thorough inspection will help them determine the issue and our experts at Morrison Plumbing know exactly what to look for. Contact our team today!

A toilet flushes money down the drain, signifying how Collinsville, IL, homeowners could lose money if they have problems with their toilet, like constant flushing.


You Experience Frequent Clogs

Most toilets clog on occasion. If you have children who enjoy flushing toys and other objects, your toilet may become clogged weekly. However, if you need to use the plunger on your toilet every other day and it’s not because of avoidable human activities, you likely have a significant problem. Keep in mind that older toilets may require more than one flush. They are also prone to random clogs.

First, ensure that the clog isn’t the result of a problem further down the pipeline. If your plumber determines that this is not the case, you should think about replacing the old toilet with a new fixture.


If you find yourself becoming the weekend plumber in your own home and you’re having to fix problems with the toilet on a weekly basis, it is time to call a professional plumber. This shouldn’t be YOUR job! Your time is valuable and enlisting the experience of a qualified professional may actually save you money in the long run, not to mention time and stress. If you suspect you need plumbing repairs or the installation of a brand new toilet, please call our expert technicians at Morrison Plumbing at (618) 408-1597, and we’d be happy to provide exceptional service for any of your plumbing needs.

Skip to content